When It Feels Like a UTI, But Isn’t

Medically reviewed by: Dr. Maria Uloko, MD, Urologist and Sexual Medicine Specialist; Written by: Megan Henken (In partnership with Uqora & MyUTI)

When Every Burn Feels Like a UTI — But Tests Say Otherwise

You feel the familiar sting when you pee. The urgency. The pressure. You’re convinced it’s another UTI. But your test comes back negative again.

If this cycle sounds familiar, you’re far from alone. Many people, especially women, experience urinary symptoms that look and feel identical to an infection, but have non-infectious or overlapping causes that standard tests often miss.

“Not all bladder pain is caused by bacteria,” says Dr. Maria Uloko, a urologist and sexual medicine specialist. “When symptoms keep returning and the tests are negative, it’s time to look beyond the bladder.”

From hormonal shifts to nerve pain, several conditions can mimic UTIs — and understanding them is the first step to getting lasting relief.

When the Culprit Isn’t in the Bladder

That familiar burning when you pee. The constant urge to run to the bathroom. The pressure in your bladder that won't let up.

Most people (and many doctors) assume this means a urinary tract infection (UTI). But what happens when your urine test comes back negative, or antibiotics don't help?

The truth is, many conditions can feel just like a UTI. Getting the right diagnosis is the only way to find real relief.

1. Hormonal Changes to the Vulvar Vestibule

The vulvar vestibule is the sensitive tissue at the entrance of your vagina. It's closely connected to your bladder—they actually develop from the same tissue before birth—and it depends on hormones like estrogen and testosterone to stay healthy.

When these hormone levels drop or get blocked, this tissue can become dry, inflamed, and painful. This can happen with:

• Perimenopause and menopause
• Birth control pills or hormonal IUDs in some people
  
• Medications that lower estrogen or block androgens
• Certain fertility or cancer treatments

When the vestibule is inflamed, you might feel:

• Burning when you pee
• Rawness or stinging at the opening
• Pain with touch, tampon use, or sex

To many women, this feels exactly like a UTI, even though the bladder and urine are fine. Doctors call this Hormonally Mediated Vestibulodynia, and in menopause it's often part of Genitourinary Syndrome of Menopause (GSM).

"Many women are treated with repeated rounds of antibiotics when the real problem is hormonal," explains Dr. Uloko. "When we identify and treat the hormone imbalance, the inflammation and UTI-like symptoms often improve."

2. Nerve-Related Pain

Sometimes the problem isn't your bladder or urine at all—it's the nerves in your pelvic area. When these nerves become irritated or overly sensitive, they can create intense pain even when there's no infection.

Here are three common examples:

Vestibulodynia (Neuroproliferative) In this condition, there's an overgrowth of pain-sensing nerve endings in the vestibule. Even light touch can feel like burning or stinging.

Pudendal Neuralgia The pudendal nerve is a major nerve in your pelvis. When it gets irritated or compressed, it can cause:

• Burning or electric shock-like pain
• Pain when sitting
• Raw, hypersensitive feelings around the vulva, urethra, or rectum

Genitopelvic Dysesthesia This condition comes from irritation of the nerve roots in your lower spine that supply the pelvic area. Even though the problem starts in your back, you feel it in your vulva, vagina, or urethra. It can feel like:

• Constant burning or tingling
• Pins and needles or "electric" sensations
• Urethral irritation with no infection

Because all of these nerve conditions can flare with sitting, peeing, or sex, they're often mistaken for recurrent UTIs. You might be told "everything looks normal," even though your pain is very real. The key is recognizing that the nerves—not the bladder—are causing the symptoms.

3. Pelvic Floor Muscle Dysfunction

Your pelvic floor is a group of muscles that support your bladder, uterus, and rectum. These muscles can become too tight and unable to relax, often due to:

• Chronic stress or clenching
• Past infections or pain
• Childbirth or trauma
• Long-term guarding against pain

When these muscles are in spasm, they can irritate nearby nerves and your bladder. You might feel:

• Pelvic pressure or heaviness
• Burning in your urethra
• Frequent or urgent urination

This can look just like a UTI, but your urine tests come back negative. Treatment often includes pelvic floor physical therapy to help the muscles relax and function normally.

4. Vaginitis and Sexually Transmitted Infections (STIs)

Infections in your vagina or cervix can also cause burning that feels like a UTI.

These include:

• Vaginitis, like bacterial vaginosis or yeast infections
• STIs like chlamydia, gonorrhea, ureaplasma, and mycoplasma

These infections can inflame the tissue around your urethra, causing burning when you pee, discharge, irritation, or odor—symptoms many people (and sometimes doctors) assume is another UTI.

Comprehensive testing is essential to identify these causes and get the right treatment.

5. Overactive Bladder (OAB)

Overactive bladder is when your bladder muscle becomes "overactive." You might feel:

• Sudden, intense urges to pee
• Needing to urinate very frequently
• Leakage if you can't get to a bathroom in time

With OAB, there's no infection, but the symptoms overlap with UTIs. Triggers can include:

• Certain foods and drinks, like caffeine, alcohol, or acidic or spicy foods
• Stress and anxiety
• Changes in your bladder's signaling system

"If bladder urgency and frequency keep coming back, or if they're affecting your daily life, it's worth seeing a urologist or urogynecologist," says Dr. Uloko. "You deserve a clear diagnosis and a treatment plan that matches the true cause, not just more antibiotics."

Why “Negative” Doesn’t Mean “Nothing’s Wrong”

Traditional urine dipsticks and cultures were designed to detect a small set of common bacteria, mainly E. coli. But not every infection fits that mold.

Many slow-growing or intracellular organisms don’t appear in a culture, and nerve or hormonal causes won’t show up on a lab test at all. So when you’re told “everything looks normal,” it may simply mean that the right test or exam hasn’t been done yet.

“A negative test result doesn’t mean you imagined your symptoms,” says Dr. Uloko. “It just means the test didn’t find the cause.”

That’s why exploring a broader diagnostic approach, including molecular testing and a thorough physical evaluation, can bring the clarity standard tests can’t.

How Modern Testing Helps Rule In or Rule Out Infection

Modern molecular testing, like PCR (polymerase chain reaction), looks for bacterial DNA instead of waiting for growth in a petri dish. This allows clinicians to detect both typical and hard-to-find organisms (including Ureaplasma, Mycoplasma, and Gardnerella) that can cause urinary or vaginal irritation.

If PCR results show bacteria, that’s actionable data for treatment. 

If they’re negative, that’s equally valuable. It tells your provider to look beyond infection for causes like GSM, IC, or pelvic floor dysfunction.

“Testing isn’t about chasing results,” says Dr. Uloko. “It’s about getting clarity so you’re not stuck in the cycle of antibiotics that don’t help.”

Platforms like MyUTI make this easier by offering two complementary PCR-based tests — the Complete UTI Test and the BV Check Test — which together can evaluate both urinary and vaginal microbiomes. This helps pinpoint whether your symptoms are driven by infection, imbalance, or something else entirely.

Finding the Right Care and Support

One of the hardest parts of navigating pelvic or bladder pain is finding a clinician who takes these symptoms seriously and understands how interconnected they are.

“These conditions fall between specialties — urology/urogynecology, gynecology, vulvar specialist and pelvic floor physical therapy ,” says Dr. Uloko. “It can take time to find someone who knows how to look at the full picture.”

Where to Find the Right Specialist

Look for clinicians experienced in sexual medicine, vulvar disorders, or pelvic pain:

• ISSWSH – The International Society for the Study of Women’s Sexual Health
• IPPS – The International Pelvic Pain Society
• AUA Find a Urologist – The American Urological Association’s provider directory
• APTA – American Physical Therapy Association

Preparing for Your Appointment

Don’t wait for your annual well-woman exam, book a dedicated visit to address your symptoms.

When scheduling, mention that you’re having urinary burning, urgency, or pain and that you’d like to explore both infectious and non-infectious causes.

“Be specific,” Dr. Uloko advises. “If you just say ‘UTI symptoms,’ you may be funneled into another round of antibiotics. Lead with what’s been ruled out and what you’re still feeling.”

Bring These to Your Appointment

• A symptom log noting when your symptoms occur (e.g., after sex, during your cycle, after certain foods).
• A list of past test results and treatments — including any antibiotics that didn’t help.
• A note about how long the symptoms have lasted and how they affect your quality of life.

Three Key Things to Ask or Expect at Your Appointmen

1. A Vulvar and Pelvic Exam
   Your clinician should visually assess the vulva, vaginal tissues, and urethral area for thinning, redness, or muscle tension. Many causes of UTI-like symptoms are visible with the right exam but often go unchecked.
2. Targeted Testing
   Request testing that looks for both urinary and vaginal organisms, including Ureaplasma, Mycoplasma, and Gardnerella.
   - If your symptoms involve both bladder and vaginal discomfort, consider both a urine and vaginal PCR test.
   - MyUTI’s Complete UTI Test and BV Check Test can be ordered directly online to help you start that process.
3. Pelvic Floor Evaluation or Referral
   Ask if pelvic floor dysfunction could be contributing to your pain or urgency. A referral to a pelvic floor physical therapist can help retrain muscles and nerves that are keeping the pain cycle active.

“These steps may sound simple,” says Dr. Uloko, “but together they’re game-changing. They shift the conversation from symptom suppression to root-cause discovery.”

The Empowered Next Step

When UTI symptoms keep returning, it’s easy to lose faith in your body or in the medical system. But these overlapping conditions are common — and treatable once they’re identified.

“You deserve care that listens to your symptoms and looks at the whole picture,” says Dr. Uloko. “That’s how we finally break the cycle of misdiagnosis and over-treatment.”

If you’re feeling stuck, start by asking for a more comprehensive evaluation and if your clinician doesn’t have access to advanced testing, you can take the first step yourself. At-home comprehensive testing options, like MyUTI, can help you clarify whether infection is part of your story, or if it’s time to focus on restoring tissue and nerve health instead.

The Bottom Line

If it feels like a UTI but isn’t, it doesn’t mean it’s in your head — it means it’s time for better answers. With modern testing, informed self-advocacy, and the right care team, you can finally move beyond guessing and get to healing.

“Our goal as clinicians,” says Dr. Uloko, “is to help you understand your body, not fear it. Once you have the right information, everything changes.”

This article was developed in collaboration between Uqora and MyUTI to help women better understand overlapping pelvic and bladder conditions that mimic UTIs. Clinical insights provided by Dr. Maria Uloko, MD.

Share article